NY investigates energy drinks

New York is investigating energy drink companies to determine if marketing claims and manufacturing practices violate state law; if so, it could affect how products are marketed to the entire United States.

Sandy Almendarez, VP of Content

August 28, 2012

3 Min Read
Supply Side Supplement Journal logo in a gray background | Supply Side Supplement Journal

The Wall Street Journal reported New York's attorney general is investigating energy drink ingredient and health claims. The article by Reed Albergotti and Mike Esterl said Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman issued subpoenas in July to PepsiCo Inc. (which markets Monster Energy Drinks) and Living Essentials LLC (which makes 5-hour Energy drink), asking for information on the companies' marketing and advertising practices. The article's source is a "person familiar with the matter."

The article said Schneiderman wants to know if energy drink companies are misleading consumers with inaccurate labeling and advertising. "The investigation is in the early stages and could expand to other companies, that person said," Albergotti and Esterl wrote. According to the article, investigators are examining whether the companies overstated health benefits and understated the effects of caffeine.

Energy drinks have been controversial since FDA released its "Guidance for Industry: Factors that Distinguish Liquid Supplements from Beverages" in 2009.  According to the draft guidance, beverages can be distinguished from liquid supplements based on factors such as the volume in which they are intended to be consumed, product or brand name, labeling, advertising and packing as a single or multiple use beverage. FDA has not issued a final guidance, but it did send a warning letter to Revolt Distribution in December of 2011 that adopted some of the principles expressed in the draft.

They controversy heated up in April of this year when Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) called for FDA to investigate energy drinks and clarify the definition of conventional food and beverages versus supplements. Durbin also asked FDA to enforce its regulatory authority over the caffeine levels in energy drinks marketed as supplements. Durbin asked FDA to review safety concerns posed by additives in energy drinks by requiring manufacturers to provide scientific evidence that ingredients, such as guarana, taurine, yerba mate, kola nut and ginseng, are safe for their intended used and when used in combination with other ingredients and caffeine. He also asked FDA to extend its 0.02% caffeine limit to energy drinks; currently, FDA enforces this limit in soft drinks, but Durbin said is not actively enforced for energy drinks.

In August, FDA responded to Durbin, saying no current data shows a significantly widespread caffeine consumption problem due to energy drinks, and said the regulatory distinction between beverages and liquid supplements is a complex decision taken on a case-by-case basis.  In its response,  FDA said the amounts of caffeine in energy drinks are similar to those found in commonly consumed beverages such as coffee. FDA further noted up as much as 400 mg/day of caffeine is not associated with general toxicity, cardiovascular problems and negative effects on bone status or calcium balance.

But FDA does not enforce state laws, and perhaps the New York probe will determine that energy drinks violate state laws. And if we look to California's Prop 65 as any indication, a state law that affects such a large market, such as New York or California, can affect the way product manufacturers create products for a much wider audience. It will be interesting to see what comes, if anything, of this New York probe.

About the Author

Sandy Almendarez

VP of Content, Informa

Summary

• Well-known subject matter expert within the health & nutrition industry with more than 15 years’ experience reporting on natural products.

• She cares a lot about how healthy products are made, where their ingredients are sourced and how they affect human health.

• She knows that it’s the people behind the businesses — their motivations, feelings and emotions — drive industry growth, so that’s where she looks for content opportunities.

Sandy Almendarez is VP of Content for SupplySide and an award-winning journalist. She oversees the editorial and content marketing teams for the B2B media brands SupplySide Supplement Journal and SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal, the education programming for the health and nutrition trade shows SupplySide Connect New Jersey and SupplySide West, the education program SupplySide Fresh for industry newcomers and community engagement across the SupplySide portfolio. She is a seasoned content strategist with a passion for health, good nutrition, sustainability and inclusion. With over 15 years of experience in the health and nutrition industry, Sandy brings a wealth of knowledge to her role as a content-focused business leader. With specialization in topics ranging from product development to content engagement, creative marketing and c-suite decision making, her work is known for its engaging style and its relevance for business leaders in the health and nutrition industry.

In her free time, Sandy loves running, drinking hot tea and watching her two kids grow up. She brews her own “Sandbucha” homemade kombucha; she’s happy to share if you’re ever in Phoenix!

Awards:

Speaker credentials

Resides in

  • Phoenix, AZ

Education

  • Arizona State University

Contact:

Subscribe for the latest consumer trends, trade news, nutrition science and regulatory updates in the supplement industry!
Join 37,000+ members. Yes, it's completely free.

You May Also Like